Are Soft Potatoes Bad? Examining Quality and Safety

Potatoes are a staple food in many cuisines and are a versatile ingredient that can be enjoyed in many forms. However, sometimes we might find soft potatoes in our pantry and wonder if they are still safe to eat. The answer to whether soft potatoes are bad largely depends on the degree of softness and other signs of spoilage.

Although potatoes may naturally become somewhat soft over time due to water loss, this doesn’t necessarily mean they are unsafe to consume. If a potato is only slightly soft but still smells fresh and has no discoloration or mold, it should be safe to cook and enjoy. On the other hand, if the potato has become very soft or mushy, has dark spots, exhibits a foul odor, or shows signs of mold, it is best to discard it to avoid any potential health risks.

Proper storage methods can help prolong the shelf life of potatoes and prevent them from turning soft too quickly. Ideally, potatoes should be stored in a cool, dark, and well-ventilated space with a temperature between 45°F and 55°F to maintain optimal freshness.

Identifying Soft Potatoes


Soft potatoes can be identified by their slightly mushy texture and wrinkled skin. While a small degree of softness is not harmful, it is important to assess the potato’s condition before consumption. A whole potato should generally be firm to the touch. If it feels soft and pliable under your hands, this may be an indication that your potato is past its prime, although it may still be safe to eat.


Discoloration in potatoes can come in many forms. A sweet potato may change color ranging from dark brown to black. On the other hand, regular potatoes may turn green when exposed to light for an extended period. The presence of unusual colors may indicate that the potato is spoiled or on its way to going bad.

Green Spots

Green spots on potatoes are a result of exposure to light, which increases the production of a toxin called solanine. Solanine can cause gastrointestinal discomfort, so it is best to cut away green spots before cooking the rest of the potato. However, if the entire potato is green, it’s better to discard it.

Mold Spots

Mold spots are a clear sign of spoilage. If you find mold spots on your potatoes, it’s best not to consume them. Mold can penetrate deeper into the potato, which could cause health issues if consumed.

Black Spots

Black spots on potatoes are usually a sign of bruising or damage during transportation or storage. In most cases, you can cut away the black spots and use the rest of the potato. However, if there are too many black spots, it’s better to discard the potato.


Bruises on potatoes are often caused by rough handling or storage conditions. Depending on the extent of the bruising, you may be able to cut away the affected area and still consume the rest of the potato.


Potatoes with sprouts indicate they are beginning to grow new tubers, which can lead to a decline in texture and taste. If a potato has small sprouts, you can remove the sprouts and use the remaining potato. However, if the potato has long sprouts, it is advised to discard it.


A strong, unpleasant odor from the potato may signal spoilage. If a potato emits a foul smell, it’s best not to consume it, as this could indicate bacterial growth and potential food poisoning.

By examining softness, discoloration, green spots, mold spots, black spots, bruises, sprouts, and odor in your potatoes, you can determine their quality and safety for consumption.

Causes of Soft Potatoes

Soft potatoes can be a result of various factors, including the presence of solanine, moisture, temperature, sunlight exposure, chlorophyll production, and dehydration. This section will explore each of these factors and their effects on potatoes.


Solanine is a natural toxin found in potatoes and other plants from the nightshade family. It protects the plant from insects, diseases, and predators. When potatoes are exposed to sunlight or begin to sprout, their solanine content increases. High levels of solanine can cause the potato to become soft and have green spots on its surface. Eating potatoes with a high solanine content may lead to gastrointestinal discomfort and, in severe cases, neurological issues.


Potatoes can become soft as a result of moisture exposure. High humidity or storing potatoes in damp conditions can cause them to absorb moisture and become soft. Additionally, washing potatoes and not letting them dry properly before storage can also lead to softness. Maintaining optimal storage conditions, such as keeping them in a cool, dark, and dry environment, can help prevent this issue.


Temperature plays a significant role in the quality and shelf life of stored potatoes. Potatoes should be stored at a cool temperature, ideally between 45 to 50°F (7 to 10°C). Storing potatoes at higher temperatures can cause them to age faster and become soft. Avoid storing potatoes near heat sources or in direct sunlight.


Exposure to sunlight can cause the potatoes to produce chlorophyll. While chlorophyll itself is harmless, it’s a sign that solanine production has increased in the potato. Sunlight can also cause sprouting and discoloration, which can lead to softness. Store potatoes in a dark place to avoid these issues.


Chlorophyll is a green pigment found in plants, including potatoes. It is responsible for photosynthesis, which allows plants to absorb sunlight and convert it into energy. As mentioned earlier, sunlight exposure can lead to chlorophyll production in potatoes. While chlorophyll alone doesn’t cause potatoes to become soft, it is an indication of increased solanine levels and other factors that can contribute to softness.


Dehydration is another factor that can cause potatoes to become soft. Over time, potatoes can lose moisture, leading to a wrinkled and shrunken appearance. Dehydrated potatoes may be softer and less appealing for consumption. Proper storage conditions, such as a cool, dark, and dry environment, can help minimize dehydration and maintain potato quality.

Storage and Handling

Proper Storage

When it comes to storing potatoes, it is important to find a cool, dark place with good ventilation. The ideal temperature range for storing potatoes is between 45°F and 55°F. Having a consistent temperature is essential, as fluctuations can cause premature spoiling. Additionally, potatoes should be kept away from direct sunlight to avoid the formation of green patches and sprouts.

Pantry vs. Fridge

While a pantry or unheated basement might be ideal for storing potatoes, the fridge is not the best option. Storing potatoes in the refrigerator can cause the starch to turn into sugar, negatively affecting their taste and texture. On the other hand, sweet potatoes have a slightly different makeup, so their storage requirements might differ from white potatoes.


Proper airflow is crucial when storing potatoes. This can prevent mold and dampness, which can lead to premature spoiling. Avoid using airtight containers, as potatoes need to breathe. Instead, consider using mesh bags or similar storage methods that allow for air circulation.

Storage with Onions

While it may seem convenient to store onions and potatoes together, doing so can actually cause both to spoil more quickly. Onions emit gases that can cause potatoes to sprout, resulting in a shorter shelf life for both. It’s better to store them separately to prevent this issue.

Mesh Bag vs. Plastic Retail Bag

Storing potatoes in their original plastic retail bags might not be ideal, as these bags can trap moisture and encourage mold growth. Instead, transfer your potatoes to a mesh bag or another storage option that allows for proper airflow. This can help maintain both the quality and shelf life of your potatoes.

Remember to regularly inspect your stored potatoes for signs of spoilage, such as soft spots, mold, or sprouts, and remove any affected potatoes from the batch to ensure the rest stay fresh and safe to consume.

Soft Potatoes and Food Safety

Safe to Eat?

Soft potatoes may not always be safe to eat. Potatoes become soft when they lose water content, which can be a sign they are starting to spoil. If your soft potato has a foul smell, dark or black spots, or feels very mushy, it is best to avoid consuming it. It is important to check for these signs of spoilage before determining if your soft potato is safe to eat or not. [Vegan Foundry offers a guideline] ( on checking if soft potatoes are safe to eat.

Edible Portions

Even if a potato exhibits some signs of spoilage, there may still be portions you can salvage. When your soft potato has minor bruises or discoloration, you can trim off the damaged sections, while keeping the unblemished and firm parts for consumption. Discard any green portions, sprouting eyes, or small green spots, as these can contain harmful toxins.

Food Poisoning Risks

Eating spoiled potatoes can increase your risk of food poisoning. Spoiled potatoes can harbor bacteria and mold growth, leading to stomach upset and other symptoms. The Andes Mountains, where potato plants originated, offered ideal conditions for these bacteria, mold, and other pathogens to thrive. To minimize the risk of food poisoning, ensure you store your potatoes in a cool, dry place, such as a root cellar, and only consume fresh, firm potatoes that show no signs of spoilage.

Green Potato Toxins

One of the main concerns when dealing with soft or spoiling potatoes is the presence of greening. This greening can occur when potatoes are exposed to light, causing the production of chlorophyll and solanine. Solanine is a toxic compound that can cause a bitter taste and, in large amounts, can lead to symptoms such as nausea, vomiting, or even more severe effects. To avoid potential harm from green potatoes, do not consume any green portions or otherwise discard the entire potato if it exhibits extensive greening.

Following these guidelines will help you assess if your soft potatoes are safe for consumption and help minimize the risk of food poisoning or other related health issues. Remember to always prioritize quality and safety when it comes to handling and eating any type of food.

Using Soft Potatoes in Cooking


When dealing with soft potatoes, it’s important to first inspect and properly peel them. Remove any green spots, sprouts, and discoloration on the skin, as well as any bruises or damage. This will ensure that you’re working with the best parts of the tubers, and it will also help minimize any off flavors.

Rescuing Overripe Tubers

If you find that you have overripe or sprouted potatoes, there are a few ways to salvage them. For instance, removing the sprouts and any soft or discolored areas can still make the potatoes edible. However, if the potatoes have excessive sprouting or black spots, it’s best to discard them.

In some cases, freezing can help to preserve the remaining starches in the potatoes. To do this, cut the potatoes into pieces and blanch them before freezing. This can extend their shelf life and give you a chance to use them in future recipes.

Cooking Techniques

Soft potatoes can still be used in a variety of dishes. To maintain the best texture and flavor, consider cooking methods such as boiling, baking, or frying. This will help to firm up the potatoes and impart a more pleasing mouthfeel. For instance, you can make mashed potatoes by boiling soft potatoes, draining them, and then mashing them with butter and cream.

However, note that soft potatoes may not hold up as well in recipes that call for grated or thinly sliced potatoes due to their reduced structural integrity. In these cases, it may be best to opt for fresh, firm potatoes.


There are several recipes that can make use of soft potatoes. Some ideas include:

  • Mashed Potatoes: As mentioned earlier, boiling and mashing soft potatoes can still result in a delicious and comforting side dish. Add seasonings, butter, and cream to taste.
  • Potato Soup: Soft potatoes can be boiled and blended with other ingredients like onion, garlic, and vegetable broth to make a creamy, flavorful soup.
  • Oven-baked Potato Wedges: Cut the potatoes into wedges, toss them in oil and seasonings, and bake them in the oven until crispy and golden brown.
  • Potato Salad: Boil the soft potatoes, and then toss them with a mixture of mayonnaise, mustard, chopped onions, and celery for a tasty, cold side dish.

Ultimately, soft potatoes can still be used in a variety of dishes, as long as you properly inspect, peel, and cook them. With care and the right techniques, you can transform overripe tubers into flavorful, appetizing meals.

Nutritional Properties of Potatoes

Potatoes are a versatile and nutritious food option, providing several key nutrients when eaten as part of a balanced diet. In this section, we will explore the health benefits of potatoes, their potassium and fiber content, and their protein and iron levels.

Health Benefits

Potatoes can be a healthy addition to your diet when prepared and consumed in moderation. They contain essential vitamins and minerals, such as vitamin C, vitamin B6, and several antioxidant compounds. However, it is important to consider the cooking method, as deep-frying or adding excessive amounts of fats can negate their nutritional value. Soft potatoes, when only slightly soft with light wrinkling on the skin, are generally safe to eat and retain their nutritional properties.

Potassium and Fiber

Potatoes are a good source of potassium, an essential mineral that supports nerve function, muscle health, and blood pressure regulation. They also provide a moderate amount of fiber, which is crucial for maintaining healthy digestion and gut function. Both cooked potatoes and sweet potatoes are rich in potassium and fiber. However, it’s important to note that the skin of the potato contains a significant portion of these nutrients, so eating potatoes with their skin can maximize the benefits.

Protein and Iron

While potatoes are not a primary source of protein, they do contain a moderate amount of this essential macronutrient, contributing to muscle growth and repair. Potatoes also provide a small amount of iron, a vital mineral for blood health and oxygen transport. The protein and iron content of potatoes can vary depending on the type (e.g., russet, sweet potato) and preparation method. Raw potatoes and sprouted potatoes should not be consumed, as they can contain harmful compounds and reduce the nutritional value of the potato.

In conclusion, potatoes are a nutritious food option with various health benefits when consumed as part of a balanced diet. However, it is essential to be mindful of the preparation method and the state of the potatoes to ensure they don’t lose their nutritional value or become unsafe to eat.

Jason Hughes
Follow Me